Our pick out
An established favourite amongst our testers, this pillow has moldable, customizable filling that provides agency toughen for back- and side-sleepers. What it doesn’t have: the lingering chemical odor we’ve spotted in every other shredded-foam pillows.
This customizable down-alternative pillow is softer than shredded foam, so it’s higher for stomach-sleepers who want much less loft than the Nest Bedding Simple Breather supplies. It’s additionally a lot much less messy to regulate.
The Nest Bedding Simple Breather Pillow has been a constant tester favourite for its agency, adjustable toughen. It’s one of the crucial comfy shredded-foam pillows we’ve discovered, and there isn’t a continual drawback with stinky foam (which we’ve encountered with shredded-foam pillows from different firms).
The Simple Breather has a cushy, cool quilt, and the shredded foam is encased in its personal cleanable internal pouch (making it the primary totally cleanable shredded-foam pillow we’ve examined). The pouch additionally has a zip, so you’ll be able to upload or take away shredded-foam filling to reach your best loft. It is a messy procedure, nevertheless it does help you reach an exact have compatibility.
The Simple Breather is available in 4 sizes, together with a side-sleeper model with a curved edge in your shoulder (which we haven’t but examined). This pillow comes with a 30-day go back coverage and a two-year guaranty.
The Sleep Quantity PlushComfort Pillow Final is the one customizable down-alternative pillow we’ve ever examined, and it’s best for stomach-sleepers who’ve a difficult time discovering the appropriate peak. (“Down replacement” is a fluffy fill, normally polyester or rayon, that mimics the texture of down however prices a lot much less.)
Maximum pillows we’ve attempted are available cushy, medium, or agency densities. However the PlushComfort Pillow Final contains all 3 choices in a single pillow: It comes with 3 sealed, detachable layers of fill that can assist you reach the most productive have compatibility in your frame form.
Maximum of our testers (even some back- and side-sleepers, who usually desire shredded foam) discovered a comfy peak and loved the cushioned toughen of the PlushComfort Pillow Final. Sleep Quantity has just lately modified its no-return coverage to a 100-day go back coverage via mail, and the corporate additionally supplies a one-year restricted guaranty on its pillows.
Improve pick out
This shredded-foam, down-alternative pillow has detachable layers, so it’s more uncomplicated to tailor to other frame shapes than others we’ve examined. And it gives numerous neck toughen for back- and side-sleepers.
This supportive but moldable down pillow has a agency density. And the corporate gives a life-time ensure—essentially the most complete of any coverage we discovered.
The Sleep Quantity ComfortFit Pillow Final is without doubt one of the loftiest shredded-foam pillows we’ve examined. And there are 3 sealed, detachable layers inside of, so this pillow is more uncomplicated to customise than any others we attempted. It’s very similar to the Sleep Quantity PlushComfort Pillow Final, however this one makes use of a mixture of shredded foam and down replacement, as an alternative of simply down replacement. (Don’t confuse this pillow with any other shredded-foam pillow we attempted, the Sleep Quantity ComfortFit Pillow Vintage, which isn’t adjustable.)
We consider the PlushComfort Pillow Final is the most suitable option for side- and back-sleepers who aren’t certain how a lot loft they truly want. That’s as a result of adjusting this pillow is tidier than adjusting our Simple Breather pick out (which has free clumps of froth that may be messy to mildew).
Like our different Sleep Quantity pick out, the PlushComfort Pillow Final, this pillow comes with a 100-day go back coverage via mail and features a one-year guaranty towards defects.
In our years of trying out, we’ve discovered that down has an excessively particular enchantment. In case you are a fan of it, notice that our stomach-sleepers particularly most popular the firm-density Garnet Hill Signature White Down Pillow, with its give and softness, to different down pillows we’ve attempted over the last 4 years (with 11 sleep testers).
This pillow is more uncomplicated to form in your shoulders and neck than different down pillows we’ve attempted. In our newest trying out, a number of back- and side-sleepers (who in trying out have in most cases most popular taller pillows) additionally preferred the agency Garnet Hill. It’s the one down-pillow pick out on this information, and it’s Accountable Down Qualified (RDS).
Garnet Hill has a 90-day go back coverage and a one-year guaranty towards defects.
Price range pick out
This adjustable pillow is extra reasonably priced than different shredded-foam pillows we’ve attempted, and it gives agency toughen for back-, side-, and a few stomach-sleepers. Alternatively, in some earlier trying out we’ve spotted a robust chemical odor.
We’ve been recommending the Xtreme Comforts Shredded Reminiscence Foam Pillow since 2016, and it used to be a most sensible pick out in earlier variations of this information. Through the years, a number of staffers and readers have reported that this pillow has every so often arrived with a particularly robust chemical odor. And after we examined 4 Xtreme Comforts pillows, part of them smelled so unhealthy that we couldn’t get to sleep; even after a number of weeks, the odor didn’t fade (the opposite part of the pillows had been odorless).
Alternatively, prior to now few years, we haven’t noticed lawsuits from readers or staffers a couple of chemical odor, so we predict the issue can have been resolved—we’ll retest in a long term replace to make certain.
The Xtreme Comforts pillow has a medium loft, and you’ll be able to mildew or alter the filling to make it comfy for other folks with more than a few frame sorts and sleep positions (even a few of our stomach-sleepers have truly preferred this pillow). It in most cases prices part the cost of the Nest Bedding Simple Breather, and the corporate gives a 30-day no-questions-asked go back coverage.
